Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Shootings Stir Emotions, Call for Access to Affordable Care

By Molly McVoy, M.D.

The tragic shooting in Arizona has spurred many emotional headlines and provocative stories in the news. News stories have used the words “insane,” “coldblooded,” “bizarre,” “evil” and “troubled.”

Whenever tragedies such as this occur, emotions are stirred and people often look for clear answers. Unfortunately, tragedies like this do not have easy answers. Whether or not mental illness is involved in this case, this may be a moment to look at every way to reduce the risk of another tragedy such as this in the future.

Rep. Giffords

U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, currently in an Arizona hospital as a result of the shooting, is a friend to the National Alliance for Mental Illness (NAMI) and has served as co-chair of several fundraisers for NAMI in Southeast Arizona.

There are so many ways in which the mental health system in the United States is broken. Treatment is often hard to access and expensive. Consistent treatment is often nearly impossible for those with severe mental illness. Advocating for improved access to quality mental health care is critically important at a time like this.

In addition, it is also important to remember that the likelihood of violence from those who struggle with mental illness is very low. Most of the violence perpetrated in this country is by individuals without mental illness. Most individuals suffering from mental illness are not violent.

No matter the cause, a time like this calls for reflection and action: examining all the factors that can be changed to minimize the risk of something like this happening in the future.

Six Tips for Talking to your Doctor about Medication

By Claudia L. Reardon, M.D.

In my last blog, I addressed the factors psychiatrists consider in choosing a given psychiatric medication for a patient. I emphasized the importance of medication selection being a collaborative process between the physician and the patient. In the midst of an appointment with a psychiatrist, though, it can be difficult for a patient to know what to ask, and when and how to ask it. This article includes tips for patients to help them work with their physicians in finding the best medications.
  1. Ask the psychiatrist, “How did you pick that medicine?” Even if you can think of nothing else to ask during an appointment, this single question will probably lead to a wealth of useful information. For example, it might lead to a discussion of the target symptoms, how the medication affects other medications or medical conditions, and side effects.
  2. Make a list of medication questions to ask your psychiatrist at your next appointment. I find it extremely useful when my patients come in with a list of questions they have made since I last saw them in my office. This way, patients are sure not to forget to ask anything important to them.
  3. Take notes during your appointments. It can be difficult to remember everything your psychiatrist says during your appointment, and so bringing a note pad and pen along to take notes can be useful so that later you can remember what was discussed.
  4. Read books. There are a number of excellent books available for patients on psychiatric medications. In my experience, patients find especially useful the book Instant Psychopharmacology by Ronald Diamond, M.D.
  5. Visit websites. Patients should be careful about which websites they visit, as not all are reliable sources of medication information. However, in addition to www.HealthyMinds.org, another reputable site is the NAMI medication website. Go to the NAMI webpage (www.nami.org) and click on the “Medications” tab on the top toolbar.
  6. Try not to be embarrassed. Many patients are embarrassed to talk about concerns they have about medications, especially side effects that they find difficult to discuss. However, remember that physicians hear about all kinds of different side effects, and it is pretty hard to embarrass a physician when it comes to talk about the human body!
In addition to these strategies, you might have found others that work for you in keeping you engaged in your medication treatment. It is imperative to keep the lines of communication open with your psychiatrist and to remember that your physician is there to answer any questions you have.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Which Medicines and When: Collaborative Process of Finding the Right Medicines

By Claudia L. Reardon, M.D.

Many patients have long and trying journeys on the way to finding medication regimens that work for their psychiatric symptoms. It isn’t always obvious why psychiatrists choose certain medications and avoid others for given patients. In this blog post, I will review the process by which a physician chooses a psychiatric medication. The more the patient knows about how the psychiatrist is thinking through the medication decision-making, the more active a role that patient can play in the process. 

Psychiatrists consider the following issues when prescribing a medication:
  1. Target symptoms. A patient might have many different symptoms, for example, depressed mood, anxiety, trouble with concentration, and severe insomnia. It is important to decide which symptoms should be addressed first, since it is likely that one single medicine will not help all of the symptoms. Doctors often prefer not to start multiple medications at the same time, as it otherwise can be difficult to figure out which medicine is helping or which is causing side effects. Thus, in a patient with the above symptoms, the physician might first choose to address the patient’s depressed mood with an antidepressant. Since trouble with concentration and severe insomnia could be caused by depression, it is possible that treatment with an antidepressant will help those symptoms as well. It is important to address the symptoms in the order that makes the most sense.
  2. Psychiatric diagnosis. The physician cannot simply treat a target symptom with a medication without knowing the overall psychiatric diagnosis. For example, depressed mood could be due to many different diagnoses, including major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, schizoaffective disorder, drug or alcohol abuse, or medical problems such as low thyroid. All of these would have different treatments. Major depressive disorder would be treated with antidepressants, while antidepressants can actually sometimes worsen bipolar disorder. Likewise, if a patient’s depression is caused by a medical problem, it is essential that the medical problem be addressed rather than simply “band-aiding” the symptom of depression with an antidepressant.
  3. Medical conditions and other medications. It is critical that the physician be aware of all the patients’ medical issues and other medications they are taking. Certain psychiatric medications would be dangerous if prescribed to patients with certain medical problems. For example, some medications can worsen seizure disorders, cause abnormal heart rhythms, or worsen diabetes. Additionally, some psychiatric medications can have dangerous interactions with other medications.
  4. Side effects. Psychiatrists must consider how a given medication’s side effects will impact a given patient. For example, a patient who drives heavy machinery for a living should probably not take a medication that causes drowsiness. On the other hand, sometimes physicians can “take advantage” of side effects. For example, if a patient is sleeping and eating poorly, the doctor might prescribe a medication with sleepiness and increased appetite as side effects.
  5. History of response. If a patient or his or her family member has had a good response to a medication in the past, that might be a good reason to choose that medicine now.
  6. Patient preferences. Finally, and most importantly, the physician must make sure that the patient is willing and able to take the medication being prescribed. If the patient feels that the side effects are intolerable, or simply cannot afford it, it doesn’t matter how reasonable the choice of medication might be since the patient will not take it. The physician should check with patient to ensure they are comfortable with the medication being prescribed. Likewise, patients should not hesitate to speak up if they have concerns about a medication being prescribed for them.

In summary, physicians consider a multitude of factors in choosing a psychiatric medication for a patient. Ultimately, the decision about a medication should be a collaborative one between the psychiatrist and the patient.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

What’s the difference between all these medications?

By Sara Coffey, D.O.


This is a question I am often asked by my patients. Several times a day we see commercials for prescription pills to treat a variety of diseases from high cholesterol to heart disease and treatment for mental illness is no different. Today I would like to talk about one of the most common mental illnesses, Depression and its treatment.

Depression affects roughly 15 million Americans adults, and it is an illness that can be readily treated with antidepressant medications, talk therapy or a combination of medication and talk therapy. Antidepressants have been around for decades and include several classes of medications that work on different chemicals in the brain, but today the first line treatment for depression are medications called, SSRI’s or Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors. For the most part medications in this class are very similar; they work by increasing the amount of serotonin between nerve cells which is thought to play a role in depression. Unlike a pain pill that works right away, antidepressants can take up to 4 to 6 weeks to have an affect.

Which SSRI a doctor chooses will depend on each individual patient. Just like every other medication, antidepressants can have side effects and interact with the body or other medications in a way that may be dangerous or uncomfortable for patients. Some SSRI’s may be more likely to make a person tired or sedated, while others may have a tendency to give a patient more energy. Depending on an individual’s depressive symptoms, your doctor might prescribe a medicine that would be more likely to help you fall asleep or feel more alert and energetic. Furthermore, certain SSRI’s have been studied more in patients with a particular medical disease, like heart disease for instance and this might leave a physician to try a medication that has research data to show that the medication is safe for their patient. Certainly, some medications work better in some patients than others, and after a period of 4-6 weeks of adequate dosages if no improvement in symptoms occurs your doctor will likely recommend increasing your dose or switching to another antidepressant to treat your depression. In some instances a physician might recommend augmenting your medication by adding another medication that works in a different way to treat your Depression.

Even if the first anti-depressant doesn’t seem to work for you, there are still other options for treatment. Newer medications that work on norepinephrine and dopamine in the brain are also used quite frequently to treat depression, and older medications to treat depression, although they often have more side effects are still effective in treating depression and can be used in refractory cases.

As a patient it is important for your prescribing doctor to know about your symptoms, side effects, and other medical history and current medications that you are taking. And, as always if you have any questions about the medications you are being prescribed don’t hesitate to ask your doctor about your concerns.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Bipolar in kids? Probably not.

By Scott Benson, M.D.

The 5-year-old little girl had been referred to a therapist by her school because of her severe disruptive behavior. The almost daily tantrums had everyone concerned. She was uncooperative with the assessment and arrangements made for further evaluation. The therapist wrote a diagnosis of bipolar disorder.

The patient was certainly reactive to any limits and her tantrums seemed like they would never end. But she slept well at night; she rarely had behavior problems with her grandparents who provided afterschool care.

After a few parent training sessions with the little girl and her parents her behavior control improved. But continued treatment was threatened when her dad tried to get her on his new health insurance. The diagnosis of bipolar got the application bumped by the computer and it took a lot of calls and several letters to get her on the policy so that her treatment could continue.

At times it seems we are a little too quick to throw a label on a child’s behavior, and bipolar disorder seems to be the most popular current label.

But new research at the October meeting of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry found that children with some symptoms of mania probably do not have bipolar disorder.

Boris Birmaher, M.D., a child and adolescent psychiatrist at the University of Pittsburgh presented his group’s research. More than 2,000 children presenting to 10 different academic centers were included in the Longitudinal Assessment of Manic Symptoms (LAMS) study. 621 were found to have elevated symptoms of mania, but the full evaluation did not find sufficient symptoms for a diagnosis of bipolar disorder. Most had attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), others had another disruptive behavior disorder. Children who did have bipolar disorder have poor function and are likely to require treatment in hospitals.

"Kids with manic symptoms don't necessarily have bipolar disorder," he told Reuters Health. On the other hand, "Many children with bipolar disorder are not being correctly diagnosed."

The LAMS study which will follow these children for five years should provide direction for the assessment and treatment of children with severe behavior problems. In the mean time parents should insist on an adequate evaluation for children with severe behaviors.

The Parents' Medication Guide for Bipolar Disorder in Children & Adolescents is a great source of information for understanding the evaluation process and treatment options. Or visit HealthyMinds.org for more information on bipolar disorder or mental health issues in children.